Every October the same debate makes its way back around, usually in a group chat. Somebody shares a post saying Halloween is pagan and Catholics shouldn't touch it, somebody else replies with a skeleton emoji and a photo of their kid dressed as a taco, and meanwhile you're standing in the candy aisle wondering whether you're allowed to enjoy any of this. (You are. Keep reading.)
The short version is that the name, the date, and the whole reason the night exists are Catholic. Along the way it picked up plenty of folk custom, and historians are still arguing about how much of that was already around before the Gospel reached Ireland and Britain. But Halloween is the front porch to three days the Church has kept for more than a thousand years, and once you know what's waiting on the other side of the door, it's hard to see October 31 the same way.
What "Halloween" actually means
"Hallow" is an old English word for holy, or a holy one, the same word we pray in "hallowed be thy name." November 1 was traditionally called All Hallows' Day (we call it All Saints' Day now), which made the night before it All Hallows' Eve. Say that fast for a few hundred years and you get Hallowe'en.
So Halloween is a vigil, the same way Christmas Eve leads into Christmas and the Easter Vigil opens Easter. The party was always supposed to point to what comes next.
Three days the Church sets aside for the dead
October 31, November 1, and November 2 belong together. Some people call them Allhallowtide, and you'll sometimes hear them described as a little triduum of the dead, with each day holding its own meaning.
All Hallows' Eve (October 31) is the threshold, the night we stand at the edge of the question most of us tend to avoid: what actually happens to us when we die?
All Saints' Day (November 1) is the joyful answer. The Church celebrates everyone in heaven: the famous saints with statues, and the countless ones nobody ever canonized, like your great-grandmother who prayed the rosary every single night or the neighbor who quietly fed half the street. The feast goes back at least to the 700s, when tradition says Pope Gregory III dedicated a chapel in Rome to all the saints on November 1, and about a century later it was extended to the whole Church.
All Souls' Day (November 2) is the tender one. The Church prays for everyone who has died and is still being made ready for heaven, the souls Catholics believe are in purgatory. The custom of setting aside a day just for them is usually traced back to the Benedictine monastery of Cluny in France, around the year 1000, and it spread from there.
A heads-up for this year: November 1 falls on a Sunday in 2026, so your regular Sunday Mass that weekend is the All Saints Mass. All Souls is the very next day, Monday, November 2. It isn't a holy day of obligation, but a lot of parishes hold a special Mass that day, and some read aloud the names of every parishioner who died that year. It's a really beautiful one to show up for.
Okay, but is it pagan?
You've probably heard that Halloween is really the Celtic festival of Samhain with a Christian coat of paint. The real story is messier than that. Samhain did exist, and some Halloween customs in Ireland and Scotland probably trace back to it. That's not as scandalous as it sounds: the Church has long taught that God was at work in every culture before missionaries ever showed up, and she has a habit of keeping what's good and baptizing it. (Pope St. Gregory the Great once told missionaries to England not to tear down the local temples, but to turn them into churches.)
Still, the date of All Saints was set in Rome, not Ireland, and a lot of the customs we know grew out of Christian practice. In England, for centuries, poor families and kids went door to door around these days asking for "soul cakes," and promised to pray for the household's dead in return. It's pretty hard not to see trick-or-treating somewhere in that story.
So the fairest conclusion is that Halloween is a Catholic feast that's picked up some folk traditions over the centuries, like most holidays have. Nobody's asking you to skip the costumes or the candy. What the Church does ask is that you steer clear of anything that dabbles in the occult, like Ouija boards, séances, or tarot, even just for fun (CCC 2116–2117), and that you remember what the night is actually for.
This is for you if death makes you change the subject
Most of us live like we'll get around to thinking about death later, and our culture definitely enables us: we keep it out of sight, we say someone "passed," we keep scrolling. Halloween is one of the only nights left where everyone, believers or not, plays with the idea of death out loud, and honestly, that's not nothing. It's a door that's already open.
And the Church is there to walk you through it. First comes the night of the question. Then a day that celebrates all the people who made it home. Then a day that remembers the ones still on their way.
You might also notice John showing up a lot on these days. Several of the readings the Church offers for All Souls and for funerals come straight from his Gospel, including Jesus promising he'll lose nothing the Father has given him (6:39), Jesus telling a grieving Martha that he is the resurrection and the life (11:25), and Jesus telling his frightened friends that his Father's house has many rooms (14:2). If you've ever been to a Catholic funeral, you've probably heard at least one of them.
A few ways to keep all three days this year
- On Halloween night, go ahead and hand out the candy (and eat some, obviously). Before bed, say a short prayer for the people on your street.
- On All Saints, look up the saint you were named for, or the one you chose at Confirmation, and read their story with your coffee. Then ask them, by name, to pray for you.
- On All Souls, write down the names of the people you've lost, put the list somewhere you'll see it all month, and pray for them. The Church gives all of November to praying for the dead, so there's no rush.
- Visit a cemetery sometime between November 1 and 8 and pray for the dead there. On each of those days, the Church offers a plenary indulgence for a soul in purgatory with that visit, under the usual conditions (Confession, Communion, and a prayer for the Pope's intentions).
- Pray the simplest prayer for the dead, the one a lot of us learned as kids: Eternal rest grant unto them, O Lord, and let perpetual light shine upon them. May they rest in peace. Amen.
Read the chapter where death doesn't get the last word
If you want to sit with these days a little longer, read John 11, the raising of Lazarus. It's the chapter where Jesus stands outside a tomb, weeps with his friends, and then calls a dead man out by name. We walk through it in In His Story: A Guide to the Gospel of John, our guided study of all 21 chapters, available starting October 27.
Rather start at the beginning? Read Chapter 1 free.
Or try Twenty-One Days in John, a printable one-chapter-a-day reading plan for $0.99. Start it on All Saints and you'll finish with a week to spare before Advent.
And if you want the next Journal post in your inbox, join the list.
0 comments